SubjectThis one mistake is tanking your email performance

Stop Emailing Your Whole List

Stop blasting. Start segmenting. Your results will thank you.

Emails
Blanket Sends = Bad Strategy
Segmentation Significantly Lifts Open And Click-Through Rates
How To Build Smarter Segments In Klaviyo

Still emailing your entire list every time? That's one of the fastest ways to tank your engagement rates and end up in the spam folder.

Segmentation helps you talk to the right people, at the right time, with the right message.

One client we worked with created an “Engaged 30 Days” segment and instantly saw a 120% lift in click rate, and a 22% lift in open rates versus their full list average.

What worked?

Built a segment of subscribers active in the last 30 days
Excluded cold users to protect deliverability
Sent relevant campaigns to micro-segments by purchasing behaviour

Real-world example 🧻

Eco-friendly toilet paper brand Who Gives A Crap uses smart segmentation to keep their email content fun and relevant. Subscribers get different product nudges based on purchase history (e.g. toilet paper vs. tissues) and new customers get light, quirky content. Longtime customers? They get loyalty nudges, referral invites, or product bundle upsells.

Who Gives A Crap segmented campaigns

Segmentation is about respect. You're not blasting. You're tailoring. That means fewer unsubscribes, better engagement, and more revenue per send. Plus, it trains the algorithm (and inbox providers) to see your emails as welcome, not intrusive.

How can you apply it? 👇

Create a ‘Engaged 30 Days’ segment in Klaviyo and:

Filter segment by ‘has opened or clicked in last 30 days’
Send your next campaign only to this group
Compare performance vs. your full list
Repeat for 60 and 90-day segments

Want this mapped to your brand?

Fifteen minutes, free. We'll look at your setup, tell you which gap is costing you the most, and how we'd close it.

Claim FREE audit